This is the weekly Q & A blog post by our Research Professor in Philosophy, Dr. William Lane Craig.
Question
Dear Dr Craig,
I have recently moved on from Christianity to agnosticism, but I regularly check out your Q and A section as much of the content there is more sensible and thought provoking than the kind of thing I hear from a lot of Evangelicals.
So I figured that if there even is a satisfactory answer to my enquiry, you'd know about it.
My question is this: what is the point of prayer? Here prayer is defined as an attempt to communicate with God.
God either can read our thoughts or he cannot. If he can read our thoughts, there is surely no need to try to transmit or broadcast them to him as he already knows what they are. If he cannot read our thoughts, then any thought-based effort to contact him is futile. It doesn't matter what type of prayer it is (eg petition, thanksgiving, repentance), there is no point in making any effort to send it up to him.
Of course, Christianity generally holds that God is omniscient and therefore able to read our thoughts, so the first of these scenarios would be the applicable one. The characteristic of omniscience makes the concept of prayer all the more redundant as it means God already knows any information that might be communicated to him, and exactly what the best thing is to do about it, so prayer could not in any way influence his decisions.
I am well aware that the Bible commands us to pray in numerous instances, but in the light of this argument this strikes me as an incredibly arbitrary thing for a good God to command, and thus makes the reliability of the Bible all the more questionable to me.
Currently it seems to me that the idea of prayer is most sensibly explained as an addictive placebo that gives people a greater sense of control over their circumstances than they actually have.
But just maybe there's something crucial I've missed, and if so I would be grateful if you could point out what that might be.
Thanks,
Joe
United Kingdom
Dr. William Lane Craigs Response
Boy, Joe, the reasons you moved away from Christianity to agnosticism had better be a lot stronger than this, or youre in real danger of backsliding!
Yes, God can read our thoughts. So how is that problematic for the spiritual discipline of prayer? You say, there is surely no need to try to transmit or broadcast them to him as he already knows what they are. Hold on, Joe! Seriously, do you think prayer is a matter of providing God information? You defined prayer as communication with God. You dont communicate with another person through a third-person relationship. You enter into what has been called an I-thou relationship. You speak to another person, not just about that person. Your girlfriend or wife would be decidedly unimpressed if you rationalized never telling her I love you on the grounds that she already knows that! Anybody that obtuse is on his way to a break-up! Two people who are in love with each other want to speak to each other, to build an intimate relationship with each other.
So, sure, God reads my mind, and that enables me to pray to Him at any moment, even when audible prayers would be inappropriate. I can shoot up a thought-prayer, Thank you, Lord! or God, give me wisdom! at a moments notice. This is what people in a relationship do. Can you imagine anyone so obtuse as to say, I dont have to thank John for what he did for me because he already knows Im grateful? Or I dont have to apologize to Susan because she already knows Im sorry?
Moreover, did it not occur to you that such personal communication may be good for you? I-thou relationships open you up as a person, to make you a more loving, transparent, and vulnerable person. Prayer to God is the same way. God knows what is good for us and so wants us to talk to Him.
Of course, Joe, Im talking about the prayers of someone who has experienced a spiritual rebirth and so is in a right relationship with God. Im not talking about the rote or scripted prayer recited by an unbeliever. Doubtless, that sort of prayer is meaningless to you as an agnostic. Your prayer needs to be something like, God, reveal yourself to me! I open my heart and life to you.
You have a second, different objection to prayer: omniscience makes the concept of prayer all the more redundant as it means God already knows any information that might be communicated to him, and exactly what the best thing is to do about it, so prayer could not in any way influence his decisions. This is an objection to the efficacy of prayer. What the objection overlooks is that God can take prayers (or the lack thereof) into account in His providential planning of the world. Knowing that Joe would freely pray in a certain set of circumstances, God may actualize a world in which Joes prayers are answered; but had God known that Joe would not pray, God may have actualized something else instead. Prayers, then, are not an effort to change Gods mind. Rather God takes account of prayers in choosing which world to actualize. Prayers thus make a counterfactual difference: if I were not to pray, then something else would have been the case instead. Knowledge of this sort is called middle knowledge, and theres
Joe, on the basis of your question, I cant help but suspect that while you may have been nominally a Christian, you never really experienced a true relationship with God. If thats right, then walking away from a nominal, lifeless religion may be the first step toward finding a life-changing, spiritual relationship with God. Keep going!
This post and other resources are available on Dr. William Lane Craig's website: